|
So, all this talk about Aluminum ferrules on small pack rods has me thinking about making my own some day. The only problem I think is that I have a Jet Mini Lathe and not a metal lathe.
I head on over to www.mini-lathe.com where I'm sure it's going to explain the difference. Nope. So I browse the site looking for obvious differences that wouldn't allow me to produce my own ferrules and reel seats but I can't find any.
With the exception of the thru-hole in the headstock being smaller, I can't find a difference. I seem to be able to get all the necessary chucks, etc.. The only real difference seems to be that the Jet runs at a slow speed of 500 RPMs. Is this were the problem comes in? A wood lathe won't run slow enough? (Jim Lowe)
The main difference, as far as I know is the tool rest. A wood lathe is intended to be used with hand held tools, a metal lathe has a tool rest that holds the cutter rigidly, and is adjustable in and out and fore and aft in very small increments. You wouldn't be able to get the tolerances with a wood lathe, even if the wood turning tools would handle the metal. (Neil Savage)
If that's all, then I'm covered. The jet mini has an adjustable tool rest. (Presumably for making pens.) (Jim Lowe)
Well, give it a try. Aluminum stock shouldn't cost too much, so if it DOESN'T work, you aren't out much. (Neil Savage)
In my opinion the electronic speed control on my Homier 7x12 is one of the major features that makes or breaks the suitability of this lathe for the various rod making steps where a lathe is needed. Having said that, I know there are many excellent lathes that are belt driven and do not have the variable speed control that the 7x(10,12,14) lathes have. I guess don't have the skill to use those lathes.
Having spent a lot of time on a wood lathe in High School wood shop, and now owning the metal lathe, make sure the headstock has a big enough through hole, the chuck has to be able to hold something as small as a ferrule, the tailstock has to be able to hold a chuck and a metal working live center, and the tool post has to be a metal working tool post. You cannot hold metal cutters in your hands like you hold wood turning tools. Another area where a wood lathe may be lacking is in the setup for cutting threads. You will need that if you plan on making up or down locking reel seats. (Darryl Hayashida)
Do you find that you have to go faster or slower with your lathe. The hole is 3/8 which I would presume would be large enough for ferrules, for now I can't see needing anything larger than a 17.
I think I'm OK regarding the metal working live center as well. The cutting thread set up is something else but as long as I limit my work to ferrules and slide band, it looks like I might be OK. (Jim Lowe)
After I get everything set up - whether it is making a ferrule or turning down a ferrule station, shaping a handle, etc. I start up the lathe slowly and let it spin at 50 - 100 rpm for a few seconds with a finger on the stop button to check if anything is out of balance, not tightened, hitting the head or tailstock, etc. If everything looks good at that speed then I speed it up until it's at operating speed, still ready to hit the off switch. If everything looks good, then I start the actual operation - cutting, sanding, whatever. This precaution has saved me many times - leaving the chuck key in for instance, and I haven't done the rod propeller yet (knock on wood). (Darryl Hayashida)
 I'm looking for some guidance on a wood lathe. I have no desire to turn metal, as in ferrule and reel seat components. All I am looking for is something for turning wood reelseat inserts and ferrule stations. What is a good small lathe suitable for these projects and what should I expect to pay? Are there good low cost new units out there and what about the used market, such as eBay? I've seen some old Craftsman stuff there and a lot of low priced new stuff I suspect is just cheap junk. Don't know anything at all about the relative quality of older Craftsman, Delta, etc. equip. (Larry Puckett)
I have been using a small Grizzly lathe for a year or so. I was a bit disappointed with it for a lot of reasons. Then I got a Jet mini lathe, and now I am pretty happy. Big difference in quality. One thing to make sure of, when you get a lathe, make sure that the spindle bore is open all the way through. My Grizzly lathe had a plastic case with electrical components in the way of the spindle bore.
Anyway, the Jet is now $199 for the old model and $299 with electronic variable speed control (which would be nice). For the same price you could get a larger lathe from Harbor Freight. But, if you want a small one, I’d stick with the Jet and the Delta. Good solid lathes, not too expensive (relatively, of course), and with good motors. (Jason Swan)
Don't get a wood lathe for rod work. I did, kept it for a year and sold it and bought a metal lathe. You can do everything on a metal lathe that you can do on a wood lathe plus much more. Also, the metal lathe is so much more precise in its construction. The head and tail stock on my wood lathe were way out of alignment. Ferrule cutting was difficult. Pay the extra $50 and get a metal lathe. (Mark Dyba)
Besides, 80% of the replies I got re: Harbor Freight quality were negative. (Neil Savage)
About a year ago I was thinking the same thing - wood lathe instead of a metal lathe. As it turned out the $300 Homier metal lathe was real close to the wood lathe prices. Unless you have other reasons for staying with a wood lathe I would get a 7x12 (or 7x14) metal lathe. The metal lathe will do all the operations you are talking about quite proficiently and if you ever in your wildest dreams consider making your own ferrule (it isn't that hard!), you will be set to do so. I also looked at it this way - at approx. $50 per ferrule the lathe paid for itself very quickly. Let me also reiterate that I feel the electronic variable speed control is something I would not do without, saving me from doing the "rod propeller" while turning ferrule stations many times. (Darryl Hayashida)
I got a Ryobi (new) a while back for about $170. The spindle (headstock?? whatever, you know- the motor driven end!) was hollow but was a bit small for butt sections so I drilled it out a bit, didn't require too much drilling, still plenty of metal left so I don't think this weakened it to any degree. The plastic housing also had to be holed in the back to run the rod through but this was no problem. I ordered a 3 jaw chuck for hex shaped rods (about $45 at the time, if I recall correctly). Works great. Pretty small and relatively light, I just chuck it under the bench when I am not using it. It has a variable speed control which I really like. So far no problems after about 3 years of use. I only use it to make handles and spin down the ferrule stations. Occasionally use it to modify some stuff for around the house (don't ask about the time I took it apart and mounted a wood kayak paddle in it to spin down the paddle shaft for my daughter's hand size- it worked but it was definitely a Nunley experience, not recommended for safety reasons). Saw one recently for about the same cost so I don't think they have gone up much since I bought mine. I thought I would do a web search for you and, ta-da!, I can't find any! However, I did find one here.
This is the exact same lathe that I have but is under a different name. I suspect Ryobi must have relabeled the lathe I have for sale under their brand name. Anyway, just one more option. (Jon McAnulty)
I started with one of the Ryobi wood lathes, worked well but I found an old South Bend metal lathe and after using both for inserts and handles all I can say is spend the extra and get some sort of metal lathe. Those metal cutting tools work just fine on wood and I just rigged a cutting tool rest and can still free hand if I really want to.
The Ryobi wood lathe is now used with a leather wheel for sharpening plane blades. (Gary Jones)
I would second what Darryl says about the Harbor Freight lathe. I exchanged e-mails with him before I bought my Harbor Freight. I am very happy with mine and the company was a pleasure to work with. The thing does a great job of turning wooden reel seat fillers, metal components and a multiplicity of other rod making jobs. I think it is hard to beat. I am getting geared up to make some game calls with it as an aside. (Ron Revelle)
Now I am confused! I thought Darryl was talking about the Homier lathe and you're talking about the Harbor Freight lathe. Did I miss some posting(s)?
Tool quality generally varies with each importer even if the manufacturer is the same. (This is not meant to imply that Homier and Harbor Freight import from the same manufacturer as I simply don't know.) (George Bourke)
They are the same lathe. There are minor differences in the electronics and bundled tool sets, but the important parts of the lathe are the same - same motor, same bed castings, same housing, same gears, etc. (Darryl Hayashida)
For what you want to do I would seriously think about the Homier 7X12. I like the features on it more than the other 7X12's, also the price. It does have the speed control on the start up. This feature alone makes it above the others. It also it has an instant emergency stop switch.
You may just want to make grips now, I assure you that if you do get a lathe there are always other things you will use it for. (Tony Spezio)
About 5 years ago I purchase a "cheap" Harbor Freight wood lathe for doing cork handles on "plastic rods". It worked well for turning cork handles but it was just not satisfactory for doing ferrules and other work for bamboo - the best I could tune the lathe "wobble/out of round" was +- about 15 mils (0.015 inches) at 4 inches outside the chuck. This is not good enough for ferrules stations and other work in my opinion. I have a Grizzly metal lathe that holds +- 1 mil at 4 inches outside the chuck which is quite satisfactory in my opinion. So I would be careful of a "cheap" wood lathe (unless it is an upscale one) and think about one that you can do both wood and metal. (Frank Paul)
 While running errands this morning I stopped by a newsstand and picked a copy of "Shop Notes" Volume 12, Issue 73. The feature article is a shop made wood lathe. This particular one has a solid head stock shaft, but, I bet things could be modified a little bit so that a hollow shaft could be used. Then the lathe would be good for reel seat fillers and ferrule stations. It will not work for anything metal. (Dick Fuhrman)
What type of Lathe you guys using to turn bamboo for ferrules?? (Dave Henney)
I use my Homier 7X12 metal lathe to drill the center hole. Slip it on a dowel that is held in the three jaw chuck and shape it with a file and sandpaper.
I will be doing an article on this in a future issue of Power Fibers. (Tony Spezio)
Are you talking about making a ferrule out of Bamboo or about turning a ferrule station? I read Dave question as being about turning a ferrule station. However, upon rereading the question, I see how it could be read as about making a Bamboo Ferrule. (Dick Fuhrman)
Homier 7 x 12. (Mark Wendt)
J. C. Bogeman modified Taig. (Neil Savage)
 I know that I will catch it for this but here goes. Does anyone here own a Jet mini lathe and if so, how do you set it up to end bore wood rod handles? (Shawn Hawkins)
Wow, that's ambitious for a Jet Mini. You will need to have a bed extension, of course. The length of a 6-7" wood grip, a similar length of drill, and a drill chuck would easily exceed the length of the bed.
I haven't done this, but if I were to do it I’d think about getting one of those nice mini-lathe steady rests that PSI and Craft Supplies has. Or make one. Then, I think it could be done with an augur bit and patience. I'd also put it in a 4 jaw chuck so that you don't risk anything if you drill too far.
I'd love to hear how it turns out. Send photos if you can. I've always really liked wood grips. (Jason Swan)
You want a tool called a lamp auger. It is a handled tool designed to be fed through a hollow tailstock, and they are usually 3/8" OD.
One other way is to chuck up your drill bit in the three jaw chuck, remove the tail stock, and shove the piece in on it's center. That's how I do all my tool handles. But without some practice and good luck you won't get it precisely centered each time. Read the section on turning tool handles in "Turning Wood" by Richard Raffin. He also has a video of the same title. (Brian Creek)
Catch it? I think that it is a very reasonable question. There are two ways to center bore a handle or wood insert. Take the square blank, and turn it down to close to OD. Chuck it in your jaws, and hold the other end with a steady rest. Once you get the bore drilled (chuck a bit in the tailstock), mount it on a piece of threaded rod and turn down to final diameter. I don't like this approach because it is tough to keep the bit from wandering about.
I use a drill press. Turn your blank using the spur driver until it is just round. Then mount it in a milling vise, and drill it halfway, then reverse. Then mount it on a threaded rod. It will be a bit off, but as you turn down to final diameter it will become center to the rod. I do the initial turning because I found that most of my blanks are not truly square, and if you are off it can cause problems later when cutting mortises and the like. Mounting a circular piece in the milling vise gives the bore hole more accuracy.
This applies to any lathe - not just the Jet. As long as you have enough bed space you will be fine. If you don't then nothing will help. (Jeff Schaeffer)
I use a drill press but with a different twist to cut down on setup time. To find the center, mark both ends of the blank from corner to corner. With a Forstner bit, drill a hole about 1/4" deep on one end. I made a plate to put on the DP table with a stud that will fit the hole & aligned with the bit. Turn the blank around and pass through the center of a mill vise and over the stud. Line up the blank with the bit and clamp the vise. No need for squares, etc. Drill as far as you can, flip the blank and align as above and drill the rest of the way.
To turn the blank: Make a mandrel from a long hex-head bolt and cut the head off. Drill a center hole on the thread end. With a couple of washers on the cutoff end for spacers, mount the mandrel in the 3-jaw so that some of the threads are sticking out of the blank. Put the blank on the mandrel till it is against the washers and use a live center. You don't need a nut because the threads will keep the blank tight on the mandrel against the washers as you turn. When finished turning, use a cutoff tool to cut to length down to the mandrel. Remove the insert and do the next one.
Another plus for this setup: After a while the washers will be the right diameter so that you can gauge when you are done turning. (Don Schneider)
Check out this web site.
He has a tutorial and will be happy to share his secrets if you ask him. You want to drill out your blank first and then put it on a mandrill before you turn it. (he sells the mandrils) That way if you are slightly skewed when you do the turning everything will come out right (as they say on this list, don't ask me how I know that}. You can do 3/8" or 5/16". You can buy the bed extension for only fifty bucks or you can make one of wood. I do a pilot hole with a 1/4' bit first. (Dick Steinbach)
 I've inherited a Grizzly wood lathe that I want to use to turn grips and ferrule stations. Unfortunately the chuck jaws do not close all the way enabling me to hold a section of a fly rod. I called Grizzly and they said they don't have a smaller chuck. Does anyone know where I can find a chuck that closes all the way. The thread is 1-12. (Gary Young)
I was able to turn a grip on my wood lathe by center drilling a 1" dowel to accept a 1/4" mandrel and I put the cork on the 1/4", held the other end with a live center. I don't think I'd try to turn a ferrule station on a wood lathe even if I had a chuck that would close on the rod. I don't think you'd be able to get enough accuracy to get a good fit. Better to hand fit the ferrules, it's not that hard and it doesn't take all that long. Most of us seem to use small metal working lathes for such work, Taig, Sherline, Homier etc. Hope this helps. (Neil Savage)
If you have a three jaw self centering chuck, it probably has reversible jaws. If it has, the jaws might be installed in the reversed position. This will keep the jaws from closing all the way. The jaws are installed this way so that it can grip a piece of hollow work internally.
Wood lathes are used a lot in this manner. To reverse the jaws, remove one jaw at a time and flip them end for end. Then with the chuck key, turn it backwards till each jaw clicks, then turn to tighten. This should catch and start closing the jaws evenly. If not, do it again till all the jaws close evenly. Be sure the jaws stay in the same slot as the slot you removed them from. Each jaw should have a number on it from one to three. in some cases the chick body is also marked. (Tony Spezio)
 Can anyone point me in the direction of a good mini wood lathe? I don't want to spend $800 on a Sherline for turning cork grips and reel seat inserts, but I would like something with a hole through spindle to be able to turn down ferrule stations if possible. I've read good reviews about the Wilton 99177, but I do not know anything about it other than a lot of pen makers use lathes like these and like them. Anyone use one like this or similar that could lend some advice? (Scott Bahn)
I think it would be hard to turn a ferrule station accurately enough on a wood lathe (at least it is for me!) Check Penn State Industries, or www.cartertools.com for a less expensive metal lathe. (I really like my Taig) No financial interest. (Neil Savage)
While I have been an advocate of finding used lathes in the want ads in newspapers and at flea markets, I have found a new source for lathes. That is Craig’s list. I regularly see used lathes, and other tools, there at good prices. (Rich Jezioro)
 I almost purchased a wood lathe today for turning cork handles "on-the-rod". I was not sure, however, what an ideal diameter hole would be through the head stock. This was a "General" brand Maxi-Lathe (Model 25-100 M1) and has a .375" hole from the manufacturer. I am sorely tempted for this and other purposes, but want to do my homework first.
Any advice? All I could locate in my own archives was a note from Don Schneider that he bored out his head stock and chuck to accept .780". (Greg Dawson)
IMHO, .375" is too small if you want to make large rods. Mine is bored out to .580". It would be fine if you want to turn handles on a mandrel, obviously. (Neil Savage)
A spindle Interior Diameter of 0.375" is too small for a lot of rod butts. Remember that the ID of 0.375 only allows a rod but of less than 0.325" to go through. If you stick to smaller lighter rods it would work for you. (Larry Swearingen)
I don't know the configuration of your lathe, but I use a regular Morse tapered Jacobs chuck to hold the very end of the hexagonal cane butt and have the handle as close to the chuck as possible and the rest of the rod hanging off the right end of the lathe. I use an "L" shaped combo of boards to hold a ball bearing that can be bought at Lowes with about a 3/8" hole in it to hold the center of the rod section and another at the rod's end to hold that. So, going from left to right, you have the headstock, the Jacobs chuck, the butt, the cork, the center support, and the outboard support. The latter two are mounted in such a way that it matters not HOW long the bed of the lathe is (mine's 36" and it's never long enough). I wrap the cane section in masking tape oriented so it won't be peeled off by the rotation direction and use a fitted sleeve (cork or somesuch) if the bearing hole is very much larger than the rod's diameter at that point so nothing flops about. Keep the support nearest the cork NEAR the cork and you'll never know there wasn't a REAL tailstock used in the op. After all, using wallboard sanding mesh and sandpaper on cork doesn't exactly create a helluva lot of side force. (Art Port)
 What is the difference between a wood lathe and metal lathe and what prevents you from turning metal on a wood lathe or vice-versa Sorry, its been 20 years since my last shop class. (Matt Baun)
What is the difference between a wood lathe and metal lathe?
- Strength of Construction to handle the heavier loads of metalworking.
- Lack of method for precisely controlling cuts. IE: no auto feed or cross slide or compound feed with micrometer adjustments.
- Lack of Low speed capability. Most wood turning is done at a relatively high rpm, much faster than the typical metal work.
You CAN turn cork handles easily if you have a headstock mounted 3-jaw chuck, maybe easier than on a metal lathe with the higher rpm capability. Again with a 3 jaw chuck you CAN turn the bamboo ferrule stations using a file, just not with the easily attainable accuracy that you can with the metal lathe. (Larry Swearingen)
Not exactly so ... my 7x12 metal lathe and my 10-x18 wood lathe have the same exact motor. They both have VSC to adjust the rpm.
The wood lathe does have a 3 step pulley so I can flip the belt to another one for higher rpm's on the wood lathe but I have never done that.
I've turned aluminum and copper and brass on my wood lathe. (Ron Hossack)
Quite a bit of difference but I think you already got the info. The only thing really the same is, they turn. (Tony Spezio)
I haven't seen this part in the answers posted though: You can turn wood on a metal lathe. In fact, a lot of pen makers prefer one for its improved accuracy. I turn reel seats on my metal lathe so I get the diameter I want. I'm not that good at making an exact diameter on a wood lathe, although I have both machines. My metal lathe won't handle long/large diameter stock though, it's a mini (Taig). (Neil Savage)

|